3450 views 4 commentsupdate:Sep 26, 2012

Wheat and Barley versus Enzymes

Ioannis Mavromichalis
I have been recently contacted by a poultry integrator to help them pick the 'right' NSP (non-starch polysaccharide) enzyme for their broiler operation. In the process of our collaboration, they became very interested in knowing why the inclusion levels for barley and wheat mattered in the final choice (as it happened, these varied quite considerably according to market prices). I thought this would be an interesting 'story' to share!

 

A diet based solely on maize contains very few anti-nutritional factors, as maize contains only 2.5% cellulose and 5% arabinoxylan. That is why we rarely, if ever, use any NSP enzymes in an all-maize diet. In contrast, a diet based entirely or heavily in barley would be extremely rich in NSP as this ingredient contains 5% cellulose, 7% arabinoxylan, and 5% beta-glucans. Wheat, is somewhere in between, with 2.5% cellulose, 6% arabinoxylan, and only 1% beta-glucans.

I admit it; the above paragraph is rather dry to read, but a careful look at these boring numbers can reveal three very important facts:

1. On average, wheat is not much different than maize, with only 2% more NSP! This could easily explain why enzyme supplementation in all-wheat diets sometimes fails to elicit a positive result.

2. Barley benefits the most from enzyme supplementation as it contains the most NSP among common cereals.

3. A diet based entirely or heavily on barley would require an enzyme product that is  pure or mostly composed of beta-glucanase. Having a xylanse would also be (marginally) beneficial, but in an all-wheat diet, a pure beta-glucanse enzyme product would be almost without any benefit.

Thus, knowing the level of use for each cereal, one can select the ‘right’ enzyme. Now, of course, not all beta-glucanases or xylanases are the same, but that is another story!

4 comments

  • no-profile-image

    Morteza Youssefi

    Do you think the using of Hemicell multi-enzyme in multi cereals grain diets can be applied or not?

  • no-profile-image

    Tariq Mushtaq

    To be very frank, we did not get consistent results with any of the multi-enzyme products in typically Pakistani poultry diets even when the ingredients used in formulations are more than 15 (including synthetic amino acids but not including trace minerals, vitamins,anticoccidial, AGP etc.).
    We don't have barley.

  • no-profile-image

    Joshua

    Phytase is enough.

  • Comment deleted by a moderator

Or register to be able to comment.